In this story
  1. From the Conservatory to Montmartre
  2. Three Piano Pieces with an Ancient Name
  3. The Instruction to Play Slowly and Painfully
  4. Enrolling at Thirty-Nine and Taking a Counterpoint Examination
  5. The Gymnopédies of 1888 and Furniture Music of 1917
  6. Debussy's Arrangements and Satie's Later Work
  7. Listening at Mahina

The short answer

In December 1888, Satie advertised his scores in La Lanterne japonaise, the magazine of the cabaret Le Divan japonais. Writing under the pseudonym Virginie Lebeau, he claimed that letters were arriving asking for his collected works, then admitted that no such collection existed and supplied an address where Gymnopédie No. 3 could be bought. The advertisement mixed an exaggerated introduction with a joke at his own expense. The young man earning his living as a piano accompanist in Montmartre wrote the three Gymnopédies that same year. Seventeen years later, he went back to school to study counterpoint.

Into the story

From the Conservatory to Montmartre

Satie entered the Paris Conservatory in 1879. He was dismissed in 1882 and readmitted in 1885, but left the following year. After coming and going from school several times, he worked as a musician in Montmartre. His first conservatory studies did not lead to graduation. Outside school, he composed piano pieces and published his own scores. After continuing to compose, however, he sought a place to study again. Entering the Schola Cantorum at thirty-nine, Satie began classes in counterpoint. He would learn compositional technique at a different institution from the school he had left in his youth.

Steinlen's 1896 poster for the touring company of Le Chat Noir.
Steinlen's 1896 poster for the touring company of Le Chat Noir.

Satie settled in Montmartre in 1887. He accompanied on the piano at Le Chat Noir and later worked at the Auberge du Clou. He played the keyboard while singers performed. Around this time, he also wrote his own solo piano works. Supporting other people's songs earned his living, while he put his own music into scores. At the Auberge du Clou he met Debussy, the composer who would later orchestrate his piano music. A relationship formed at his workplace as a musician led to new arrangements and performances.

Le Chat Noir, founded by Rodolphe Salis in 1881, brought together poets, singers, writers and painters. It presented songs and shadow theatre and published a magazine. Shadow theatre used light to project figures onto a screen, moving them as a story unfolded. The people producing the cabaret's performances and publications used the same premises. Piano accompanists played music, poets and writers supplied texts, and their performances and magazine reached audiences and readers.

Three Piano Pieces with an Ancient Name

Satie wrote the three Gymnopédies in 1888. The autograph score of the first gives Paris as its place of composition and February 1888 as its date. He wrote it not long after moving to Montmartre. The manuscript records when one piece was completed, and the advertisement provides an address where a score could be bought. Before these piano pieces appeared on recordings, Satie wrote them by hand and introduced them through printed scores.

The first page of Satie's handwritten Gymnopédie score.
The first page of Satie's handwritten Gymnopédie score.

The name Gymnopédie comes from an ancient Greek festival and dance. An early score of No. 1 also carries the subtitle Ancient Dance. Satie used this term as the title of a piano piece written in Paris. A title referring to an ancient dance appears alongside notes written for the modern piano.

The early score also included lines from Les Antiques by his friend, the poet Contamine de Latour. That poem contains the dance names sarabande and gymnopédie together. Having chosen a dance name for his composition, Satie also introduced a poem in which that name appeared. He placed his fellow poet's lines in the score of his piano piece. The early publication combined music Satie had written himself with words by his poet friend.

The Instruction to Play Slowly and Painfully

Mahina's lunch and dinner playlists include Gymnopédie No. 1 performed by Anne Queffélec. The track is marked Lent et douloureux, an instruction to play slowly and painfully. Satie combined a word indicating speed with one describing emotional character. Even though a piece on a compilation album may be known as calm piano music, the original score preserves both expressions chosen by its composer.

The piece combines slow accompaniment in three beats with a simple melody. Satie placed chords next to one another without immediately resolving the dissonances within them. Dissonance is a combination of notes sounding together that creates tension. Rather than immediately relieving the tension when moving to the next chord, he wrote so that its resonance could continue to be heard.

The melody continues above the repeating accompaniment. The music repeats a small amount of material while sustaining the resonance of the chords. Satie chose simple materials, wrote music in three beats and specified its speed and character through his performance instructions.

Enrolling at Thirty-Nine and Taking a Counterpoint Examination

In 1905, Satie entered the Schola Cantorum at thirty-nine. Seventeen years had passed since he wrote the Gymnopédies in 1888. This time he studied counterpoint, the compositional technique of making different melodic lines proceed together. He began these studies to broaden the vocabulary and organisation available in his own music. A composer who had already published piano pieces was studying the relationships between melodies afresh. Having worked in cabarets and published his compositions, Satie returned to being a student attending classes and completing assignments.

The Paris Schola Cantorum building in a photograph by Atget from 1900.
The Paris Schola Cantorum building in a photograph by Atget from 1900.

In 1908, Satie passed the end-of-year counterpoint examination with very high marks. A certificate signed by Vincent d'Indy states that he was also qualified to begin composition studies. The student who had enrolled at thirty-nine attended classes and completed his examination. A composer who had left the Paris Conservatory, worked in cabarets and published piano works now received an assessment from the Schola Cantorum. Having used simple chords in the Gymnopédies, he learned techniques for handling several melodic lines together. The school recorded the results of those studies in grades and a signature.

In Socrate, written in 1918, Satie treated Plato's dialogues in music. Whereas the Gymnopédies had carried the name of an ancient dance and his friend's poetic lines, this work had voices sing Plato's words. The two works drawing on antiquity use different musical forces. One consists of piano pieces with titles and poetic lines; the other is a vocal work singing an old text. Satie chose words from older literature and dance for different compositions. After the piano works from the period when he advertised scores in a cabaret, he continued using literature as musical material.

The Gymnopédies of 1888 and Furniture Music of 1917

Satie conceived furniture music in 1917, later than the Gymnopédies of 1888. Writing to Cocteau, he criticised the practice of borrowing waltzes or operatic fantasies for various occasions. He explained that he would write music specifically suited to everyday needs instead of using pieces intended for other purposes. His idea was to make music part of daily life, as furniture is placed in a living space. Twenty-nine years separated his solo piano works from the explanation of this idea.

On 8 March 1920, Satie's furniture music was performed between parts of a play by Max Jacob at the Galerie Barbazanges. The event placed theatre and music in the same space occupied by the audience. Satie sought a use different from an independent programme demanding concentrated listening to music alone. He presented at an actual event the music for everyday needs that he had described to Cocteau. Much time had passed since he sold his own piano scores in 1888. He was now considering how music could be used in a gallery where another writer's play was being performed.

Satie showed an interest in the role music could occupy in everyday spaces. He criticised to Cocteau the practice of borrowing waltzes and operatic fantasies for other occasions and declared that he would create music suited to daily life. This idea can be connected with the background music that later became widespread. At the time, Satie was particularly concerned with reducing sound that overwhelmed conversation. When people talking and music being heard shared the same space, he sought to compose according to that space's use.

Debussy's Arrangements and Satie's Later Work

Debussy orchestrated Gymnopédies Nos. 1 and 3. The arrangements were performed under Gustave Doret at the Salle Érard in Paris on 20 February 1897. A fellow composer distributed Satie's piano music among several instruments. Debussy, whom Satie had met in a cabaret, introduced the music in a different instrumental setting. At this concert, two pieces by the composer who had advertised his own scores were presented by a conductor and orchestra.

Claude Debussy photographed at the Nadar studio.
Claude Debussy photographed at the Nadar studio.

In 1888, Satie gave piano pieces the name of a dance and advertised their scores in a magazine. In 1905 he enrolled to study counterpoint, completing his examination in 1908. Later he proposed furniture music and turned Plato's words into song. A man working as an accompanist wrote his own solo pieces and returned to classes after already publishing music. In the Gymnopédies score, he wrote the instruction slowly and painfully; in the sales advertisement, he used exaggeration and humour. Satie introduced his music by writing its titles, its notes and the words publicising the scores himself.

Listening at Mahina

At Mahina, we play Gymnopédie No. 1 performed by Anne Queffélec. If you recognise it, you might tell your companions about Satie's playful score advertisement or his return to student life at thirty-nine.